In stock markets, different investors follow different approaches like technical analysis, fundamental analysis, value investing, growth investing, special situations investing, intraday trading, swing trading, momentum/factor-based investing and many more. Each of these investors is looking at the same information (macroeconomic as well as microeconomic) but may act differently based on her investing approach.
Therefore, we try to understand the underlying thought process of an investing approach to understand the investing decisions.
Different Perspectives on Stock Investing
1. Stocks as Fluctuating Electronic Tickers
One group of investors believe that stocks are just pieces of paper (or electronic tickers/symbols) whose value goes up and down. In this approach, investors believe that instead of the underlying business, they should just look at the movement in the share prices and attempt to find various triggers that may predict upcoming up or down movement in share prices and take their investment position accordingly.
Under this view, investors are indifferent to which company, which business, and which promoters they invest in.
A benefit of this approach is that investors do not get emotionally attached or fall in love with their stocks. These investors claim to follow systems-based approaches, i.e. fixed rules of decision-making, and claim to make objective decisions with a clear mind without getting influenced by behavioral biases.
However, we need to accept that, as a fact, wherever humans make decisions, some psychological predispositions/biases are bound to enter decision-making whether we are consciously aware of it or not.
Moreover, if an investor treats stocks purely as moving tickers and ignores the underlying business, then stock investing might feel like betting in a lottery. There is a famous theory, the Random Walk theory of stock price movements, which claims that stock price movements are completely random and stock price movements of previous days cannot be used to predict future price movements.
This may be one of the reasons why the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) found that almost 90% of traders (equity derivatives) lose money in stock markets.
Nine out of 10 equity F&O traders lose money, 84% of them are men, 75% under 40: SEBI study
2. Stocks as Part-Ownership in the Business
Another popular view of stock investing is that stocks are a part-ownership in the business of the company. This view assumes that minority shareholders are partners with the promoter in the business and both of them (the promoter and the minority shareholders) benefit from the business performance of the company. This part-ownership also gives an investor the right to vote on key decisions and receive dividends.
The investor believes that her success is linked to the success of the business of the company; therefore, she puts in time and effort to understand its industry, market position, and historical performance and even tries to predict its future performance.
This approach is beneficial for investors because it brings a long-term perspective of investment to investors’ minds. She avoids short-term thinking of making quick profits and does not treat stocks as a lottery.
The Shortcomings of Viewing Stocks as Part-Ownership
A big challenge of the “part-ownership” view is that each retail investor owns only a very minuscule share of the company. With such a small shareholding, she is not able to influence any major decision of the company. Though in her mind, she might assume herself to be a part-owner, for the majority shareholder/promoter of the company, she may not even exist.
The promoter may continue to treat the resources of the company as her personal ones and may use them for her own benefit with a complete disregard for whether such decisions are benefiting the minority shareholders or not.
We noticed one instance where the promoter made the company give large loans (intercorporate deposits, ICDs) to itself and in turn, removed almost all the cash balance of the company and even made it take debt from banks to give these ICDs. We have elaborated on this example in the article linked below.
Why Management Assessment is the Most Critical Factor in Stock Investing?
This challenge is true even for larger public investors who own a significant stake in the company. Large investors may have the ability to influence the company’s decisions by their voting on the board of directors; however, even they do not own direct control over the day-to-day operations of the company. Moreover, they can only vote on the matters which are brought to them in board meetings.
We have seen cases where promoters could take steps to siphon off money from the company without the board even coming to know of it. You may read the following case to learn more.
Malvinder & Shivinder Singh took Rs 5 bn out of Fortis without board nod: Economic Times
The Peaceful Investing Approach: Faith in the Promoter
We, as investors following “Peaceful Investing”, believe that a stock is NOT a part-ownership in the business of the company. Instead, we believe that a stock is FAITH in the integrity of the promoter/management of the company.
During our analysis of companies, we have come across numerous instances where promoters have moved outside the existing cash balance of the company (representing past profits). We have also encountered cases where promoters have made companies take loans from banks (which companies will have to pay from future profits) and then moved the money outside.
Therefore, if the selection of the promoter is not good, then the promoter can spoil the past, present as well as future of the company’s business.
Please note that the promoter of the company stands as a big wall between the fruits of the good business performance of the company and retail shareholders. If the promoter chooses to, then she may not let the business profits flow to the minority shareholders, however good the business performance of the company may be.
If we have to answer the question “What is stock investing?”, then to us it is to benefit from the entrepreneurial spirit of the promoter. We keep the belief that the promoters of our invested companies will work hard to grow their business and in turn, generate wealth for themselves, and in this process, we as minority investors will piggyback on this opportunity and benefit too. This essentially is “Peaceful Investing”.
There are two important aspects to the “Peaceful Investing” approach. First, our focus is on the performance of the business and not on the stock price; and second, the promoter is the key decision-maker about the business. We can only observe the decisions and actions of the promoters and then either stay invested or sell the stock and exit.
Studying the Company and the Promoter Before Investing
In Peaceful Investing, it becomes very essential to do an in-depth analysis of the promoter, her shareholder-friendliness as well as the business that she is running.
We do this analysis by reading through the long history of the company which is available through annual reports, credit rating reports, news articles and other publicly available documents. We attempt to analyse the business strengths of the company, how it navigated during difficult times like the 2000 dot-com bubble, 2008 global recession, demonetization, GST implementation, 2018 NBFC crisis etc., and what the promoters decided about the company’s resources and minority shareholders.
Growing a business and taking it to the heights of success is a multi-decade-long journey. Therefore, once we have found the right company and the right promoter, then we intend to stay invested with them in this multi-decade-long journey. In this journey, the movement of the share price over weeks, months, quarters or even years may not reflect the true wealth-creating ability of the company.
Therefore, we do not give a lot of importance to share price movements other than deciding whether the current share price is a good buying opportunity or it has moved beyond our preferred buying range. In this journey, we do not attempt to sell and book profits on every share price rise or to trade in and out of the companies for a few percentage points.
This approach has helped us in staying invested in successful businesses over long periods, and we have held some of our invested companies for more than 10 years.
What is the Real Aim of Peaceful Investing?
One of the aims of investing is to generate a sufficient passive income that can take away the burden of compulsory work from the investor. If one goes further, then the amount of passive income should also increase with time so that it can take care of inflation as well.
If an investor looks at this aim in a literal manner, then she would expect that the portfolio should increase consistently due to the continuous addition of new capital (savings) and investment returns on existing capital.
However, the actual on-ground performance of the portfolio is hardly a consistent increase in its value. The changing portfolio size looks like a complete roller coaster ride with periods of sharp decline followed by periods of sharp increase and then long periods of stagnation.
For example, during last 10 years (2016 to 2026), investors saw many such periods of sharp movements:
- Strong up move during 2016 to 2018 led by small and mid-cap stocks.
- Fall off a cliff during February and March 2020 (Covid panic) when returns of the last many years (even a decade) were wiped out in two months.
- Strong up moves from April 2020 to October 2021 when markets realized that the world is not going to end with Coronavirus and that humanity will survive.
- Long stagnation and sideways movements following October 2021.
When an investor goes through such contrasting periods in stock price movements and witnesses her portfolio size move all over the place, then she is usually confused about what she should expect during her stock investing journey. If she keeps a long-term investment horizon, then would her portfolio become more stable and consistently increase in value? If that is not possible, then should she always be on her toes and sell her stocks on the slightest sign of trouble to protect her gains?
During our stock investing journey of nearly two decades, we have seen numerous phases of up moves and down moves in stock prices. These fluctuations in the portfolio have taught us that we cannot expect a consistent increase in portfolio value during our investing journey.
Turbulent periods leading to a sharp decline in portfolio arrive unannounced. Similarly, long periods of stock market appreciation also start without any big announcement.
When markets started their up move at the end of March 2020, then hardly anyone believed that stock prices would be on a near one-way upwards journey until October 2021. At that time, some investors were still talking about closing down stock markets.
We do not have any measure or indicator to judge in advance when the bear or bull market is about to start and how long it will last. It is always in hindsight that investors may connect the dots and reason out that certain triggers were obvious when a certain bull or bear market started or when the market changed its trend.
Avoiding a Permanent Loss of Capital
Since we cannot predict market movements in advance, in Peaceful Investing, we focus on avoiding a “permanent loss of capital” in our portfolio. Permanent loss of capital is when a company fails in its business and completely destroys shareholders’ wealth.
In the real world, companies keep on failing and shutting down. Examples like Jet Airways, Kingfisher Airlines, DHFL, IL&FS, Varanium Cloud Ltd, numerous Anil Ambani group companies etc. come to our mind when we think of a permanent loss of capital.
If we can avoid a permanent loss of capital, then the markets, the companies, and the promoters will take care of the generation of returns in our portfolio. And in this journey, we do not need to worry about bear markets or bull markets or stagnant markets and also temporary down phases in the business performance of companies. In our decades-long investing horizon, multiple such periods will come and go.
Until now, we have been lucky that our portfolio stocks have not witnessed such a loss. However, as markets, life and business environment are uncertain, we do not know when some negative surprise will hit us and we would see a blow-up in any of our invested companies. Therefore, we continuously monitor our stocks so that we minimize the possibility of such a blow-up.
If we can avoid any blow-up in our portfolio stocks and stay invested in them while they grow their business, then over a long period, our portfolio companies will generate significant wealth for their shareholders.
This is the aim of Peaceful Investing.
Regards,
Dr Vijay Malik
P.S.
- Subscribe to Dr Vijay Malik’s Recommended Stocks: Click here
- Bengaluru “Peaceful Investing” Workshop | 31 Jan 2027: Register Here
- To learn stock investing through videos, you may subscribe to the Peaceful Investing – Workshop Videos
- 25% savings on buying our Stock Analysis Excel Template and all ebooks together: Analysis Package: Excel Template + All eBooks (25% savings)
- To download our customized Stock Analysis Excel Template for analysing companies: Stock Analysis Excel
- Learn about our stock analysis approach in the e-book: “Peaceful Investing – A Simple Guide to Hassle-free Stock Investing”
- To learn how to do business analysis of companies: e-book: Business Analysis Guide
- To pre-register/express interest in a “Peaceful Investing” workshop in your city: Click here
Disclaimer
I, Vijay Malik, am a SEBI-registered Research Analyst (Regn. No. INH100008364). This article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell any securities. Investors should do their own research before making any investment decisions.
I, or my immediate relatives, do not have any financial interest in the companies discussed as on the date of publication of this article, nor do we hold one per cent or more of the securities of such companies at the end of the month immediately preceding it. I do not have any material conflict of interest and have not received any compensation or other benefits from the companies or any third party in relation to this article during the 12 months preceding its publication. I have not served as an officer, director, or employee of the subject companies, nor have I been engaged in market making activity for them.





