The current article aims to provide a framework for the detailed analysis of any stock before we delve deep into the threadbare analysis of any company for making an investment decision about its stock.
It is said that there is no single path to success. Similarly, there is no single defined way of analysis to find a good company. Investors can analyze a company in many different ways depending upon their stock-picking approach.
An investor, who follows technical analysis, would study past stock price & volume data and various indicators derived from this data on charting software. Her analysis would focus on finding stocks whose charts show a defined pattern where she can predict future price and make buying/short-selling decisions about the stock accordingly. Her aim is to find a company whose stock is set for a rise/fall in near future.
1) Growth Investing Approach:
An investor, who follows the growth-investing approach of fundamental analysis, would like to study a company like an entrepreneur. She would focus on a company’s product, target market, suppliers, customers, management, financials etc. She would want to know the strength and sustainability of the business of a company. Her aim is to find a company that is going to increase its earnings in future. Her belief is that when a company increases its earnings, the demand for its stock will increase. Increasing demand for the stock would lead to an increase in the price of the stock of the company. The investor would gain from an increase in the stock price as well as dividends to be received from the company in future.
She focuses on finding companies, which have a sustainable business advantage, which can last for decades so that she need not shift out of the stock of a company every few days. She thinks like the owner of the company and remains invested in it for decades.
2) Value Investing Approach:
An investor, who follows a value-investing approach of fundamental analysis, would focus on finding the fair value of the company. She would focus on the assets and earning potential of the companies. She tries to find out the companies whose stocks are priced at a discount to the fair value. The deeper the discount she can find, the better it is!
My Approach to Stock Investing
I follow a bottom-up fundamental analysis approach in which I look for high growth companies whose stocks are available at attractive prices. I focus on finding companies, which have grown their sales & profits at a good pace in past and have the business strength to keep growing in future. I look for companies, which have low debt as it offers safety & a potential future route to raise funds. I try to find out companies whose stock is selling at low valuations so that it can offer a huge margin of safety. I believe that if the earnings of a company increase then stock price would also rise. However, no one knows the timing of stock price rise and this is the uncertainty/risk, which requires patience of staying put with good stocks. The patience of staying invested in good companies is rewarded handsomely.
Detailed Analysis of a Company:
There is no particular order in which an investor should approach these sections. One may start from financial analysis or management analysis. However, all the four sections are essential and none can be left unanalyzed.
A) Financial Analysis:
The aim of financial analysis is to analyse the amount of income it earns in sales, amount of profits it is able to retain for shareholders after factoring in all expenses & taxes and the growth in sales & profits over past. The financial analysis also focuses on the sources of funds, which a company has used for creating its assets. It also involves the analysis of the amount of cash it generates from its operations and utilization of this cash, whether for investments or debt repayment etc. The aim is to find companies, which have a healthy financial position that can offer the potential for future growth.
Financial analysis involves a reading of annual reports of a company. It comprises of detailed analysis of three main financial statements:
1) Profit & Loss Statement (P/L):
This section of financials provides details of total income that a company has earned in a year (also called Topline). It provides details of all the expenses the company has incurred to earn the topline. It also provides details of the taxes the company paid to the govt. authorities. The part of topline, which remains after meeting all the expenses and taxes, is called net profit or Bottomline.
I focus on companies which earn a lot of money (topline), use minimum amount to earn that money, pay the due amount of taxes on its profits and increase the sales (topline) & earnings (bottom line) year on year.
2) Balance Sheet (B/S):
This section of financials provides details of all the assets and liabilities of a company on the last date of the financial year. In the Indian context, it provides details on March 31 of any given year.
Liabilities are the sources of funds, which a company has utilized to purchase all the assets it owns. The usual sources are shareholder’s own money (equity), retained earnings (profits earned but not distributed to shareholders) and debt (borrowings from banks and other sources)
Assets provide details of the utilization of the money raised under liabilities. Assets comprise of fixed assets, investments and current assets. Fixed assets are permanent fixtures that generate revenue year after year for the company e.g. plant & machinery. Investments reflect the money that the company has invested in different other companies, joint venture, subsidiaries etc. which are expected to earn money for the company’s shareholders.
Current assets are usually consumed within next one year. Current assets include inventory that gets consumed and gets sold as a finished product within a year, cash & similar investments kept by the company to meet day to day requirements and money due from customers (account receivables or debtors) and loans given to different parties that are expected to be received back within a year).
I focus on companies, which use a minimum amount of debt and create assets that keep on generating revenue for the company year after year without the need for frequent expenses to maintain these assets.
3) Cash Flow Statement:
This section provides details of the cash that a company has generated in the last financial year from operation (cash-flow from operations or CFO). This section also includes details of cash used in making investments or received from selling investments (cash-flow from investing activities or CFI) and cash raised from financial institutions as borrowings or repaid to them during the last year (cash-flow from financing activities or CFF)
I focus on companies, which generate a good amount of cash flow from operations that can take care of their requirements of investment (CFI) and repayment of debt (CFF). If a company generates so much cash that after taking care of CFI and CFF, it still has surplus left, it is a dream company and I buy as many stocks as I can (Shop till you drop!!).
Some knowledge of accounting can be a good advantage to do a financial analysis of a company. However, it is not required to be a master of accounting for stock investing. An investor who does not have a background in finance & accounting, but is willing to put in the effort needed to read the annual reports, will get the required knowledge of accounting during analysis. Therefore, I firmly believe that anyone irrespective of educational background can be a great stock picker.
Learn about detailed financial analysis of a stock here: How to do Financial Analysis of a Company
B) Business & Industry Analysis:
I am a bottom-up fundamental investor. Therefore, I give more weightage to the business qualities of a company than the industry it operates in. In fact, I follow Peter Lynch when he says:
Moderately fast growers (20 to 25 percent) in non-growth industries are ideal investments.
I try to find a company, which has shown good growth in sales & profits in past years. I consider such a company a good investment candidate irrespective of its industry. I try to focus on the performance of the company in comparison to its industry peers and try to find out if it has any business advantage over its peers.
Warren Buffett calls this business advantage “Moat”. Many investors visit company stores, manufacturing plants, meet its customers, suppliers, vendors etc. to find out the moat of a company. If time permits, an investor should do these activities, as these will give her information that the stock markets are yet to come across. However, many individual investors including me, have limited time left after the daytime job and therefore, cannot go to the market and meet different stakeholders of the company.
Therefore, I use consistent growth in sales in past as a substitute for market research and try to analyse it further. If I find a company has been growing at a rate of 20% year on year for the past 10 years whereas its peers are growing only at 10% or less, I analyse it further. If 10 year back it had a single manufacturing plant and it has increased its capacity to 5-6 plants now where it is able to sell the entire production of these 5-6 plants, then the company is bound to have a sustainable advantage “Moat”.
Moat can be discovered after doing market research if time permits but detailed analysis of past growth, other financial parameters like higher profit margins as compared to industry peers, can easily provide an investor with the indication of a sustainable business advantage.
We have the advantage of witnessing one of the most severe recessions ever since 2008. It is a blessing in disguise as we can analyse the performance of any company during this recession and see how its business fared. If it was able to show sustained growth during 2008-2014, it is expected to have a good business advantage, which has sustained it in bad times and it might help it to grow its business further when good times (Achche Din) arrive!
Learn about detailed business & industry analysis of a stock here: Business & Industry analysis of a Company
C) Management Analysis:
Management is the most important parameters and I give it more importance than any other parameter. I want to invest in companies, which are run by honest people whom I can trust with my personal money. A crook manager will always find more than one way to cheat shareholders. I avoid companies where I see even the slightest sign of compromise of integrity.
Management analysis is mainly a subjective exercise, however; it contains some objective parameters as well. We should read the profile of promoters, search about their credentials, any issues, penalties, regulatory actions etc. about them from public sources (e.g. Google). We should do similar checks about independent directors as well. Once we are convinced that there is nothing to question their character & integrity then we should move ahead with further analysis.
As an investor should stay invested in stocks of a company for decades, management succession plans become a vital factor. As in India, most businesses run in families, we should see whether the key promoter has introduced her next generation into the business. We should read about the next generation. We should find out their education credentials and the amount of experience they have already had working under the guidance of their parents.
Certain parameters like salary being paid to children of the key promoter are a good indicator of values being instilled by promoters in her children. I was amazed to find a company, which made about Rs. 50 cr. (INR 500 million) in profits but the promoter paid only Rs. 10,000/- (INR 0.01 million) per month to his daughter who had joined the board of directors. Today, I am heavily invested in the stocks of that company.
For any further information, we should always call the company secretary or investor’s relations officer of the company before we commit our hard-earned money to any stock.
Many objective parameters can provide indications about investor friendliness of the promoters & management:
- A comparative analysis of salary drawn by promoters and the profits of a company is a good parameter. The promoter should not have a history of seeking an increase in remuneration when the profits of the company declined in past.
- Successful execution of increase of production capacity especially by greenfield plants is a good indicator of competent management. It is very good if the capacity addition has been done without facing any delays.
- A company that has consistently increased its dividend payout with an increase in profits in past usually has good management.
- Purchase of shares of a company by its promoters is a sign of a good promoter. However, the selling of shares by promoters is not necessarily negative. Company’s shares are usually the promoter’s biggest asset and they usually sell it whenever any cash requirement arises in personal life.
Learn about detailed management analysis of a stock here: Management Analysis of a Company
D) Valuation Analysis:
There are many parameters, which need to be studied to analyse the valuation levels of a company. Some of the important parameters are:
1) Price to Earnings ratio (P/E):
I believe that P/E is the single most important parameter to analyse whether the stock of any company is overvalued or undervalued at any point in time. It is calculated by dividing the current market price (CMP) of stock by profit/earnings per share (EPS). It represents the price an investor pays to buy Rs. 1 of earnings. I prefer the companies, which are available at low P/E ratio, preferably less than 10.
2) Price to Book Value ratio (P/B):
It is calculated by dividing the CMP of a stock with the book value (shareholder’s equity + retained earnings) per share. It represents the price an investor pays for Rs. 1 of net assets after settling all outsider liabilities of a company. I find P/B ratio irrelevant due to usage of the historical cost of the company’s assets while calculating book value. The historical cost might not represent the current market value of a company’s assets. However, the P/B ratio is very important for companies in the financial sector where most of the assets are cash assets and book value is a good indicator of the net worth of the company.
Benjamin Graham said that an investor should look for companies where P/E * P/B is < 22.5. However, I focus mainly on companies with P/E <10 while ignoring the P/B ratio.
Every investor develops her own parameters as her investing experience grows and I believe that every reader of this blog would be able to find her favourite parameter as she keeps analyzing more and more companies.
3) Market Capitalization:
It represents the value of all the shares of a company and indicates the value for which the entire company can be bought at any point of time. Companies are divided into micro-cap, small-cap, mid-cap and large-cap based on their market capitalization. I prefer investing in companies, which are currently micro-cap or small-caps as these companies represent the section of the economy, which can grow fast and become future large-caps.
There are many other parameters like return on equity (ROE), return on capital employed (ROCE), dividend yield etc. which are analysed by different investors to find out stocks which hold the potential for providing good returns in future. We would analyse many such factors in the subsequent article in this series that would be dedicated to valuation analysis.
Learn about detailed valuation analysis of a stock here: Valuation Analysis of a Company
In the current article of this series “Selecting Top Stocks to Buy”, we have discussed various aspects of the analysis of any company. An investor should analyse the companies from each of these angles: financial, business & industry, management and valuation before she invests her hard-earned money in any stock.
The investor should realize that her rejection rate of stocks would always be high as good companies selling at attractive prices are always difficult to find. However, finding one good stock each year is more than sufficient. 10 good stocks in one’s lifetime can make one a billionaire. The investor should never be in a hurry. She should learn to be patient and should hold the impulse to buy a stock if she does not find good stock.
The investor should have very strict stock selection criteria for adding stocks in her portfolio so that she can be confident that only the right stocks are selected. Easy selection criteria will lead to many undesirable stocks in the portfolio, which will require selling soon after buying. This would lead to wastage of time and effort put by the investor in the stock selection. The key is to find if a company would survive for the next 25-30 years and whether the investor can visualize it being there after many decades. Economic cycles of upturn and downturn will be there. A good company can weather all of them and come out a winner.
How do we go about analysing stocks in details?
Very detailed as always! I have a few questions for you Sir.
- How much time do you usually spend to analyse a particular company?
- Should one set a time limit in the first place?
- How do you know where to begin?
- And how does one realize which would logically be the next step? What to do in case one does not find sufficient data (even though there is no dearth of sources of Secondary Data) for a particular step in the framework of the analysis?
- Most importantly in case of data is not available how to use surrogate indices?
- Because over and above the framework you have laid out to analyze businesses I have seen in all your “Stock Analysis” articles a story which connects the dots for the readers. (For e.g. you began the analysis of this company by stating the health of the company during FY 08-10.) How do you build upon this?
Once again I would like to thank you for sharing with us (especially for those who have interest but not a relevant degree) such valuable information and I hope you continue doing so.
Thanks for writing to me! I am happy that you found the article useful.
1) How much time do you usually spend to analyse a particular company?
It does not take a lot of times to reject a company if it does not meet the basic criteria. The stock analysis excel template (compatible with Screener) helps in this regard by presenting the relevant data with parameters that I prefer to analyse as a dashboard and therefore, saves a lot of my time.
However, if I need to analyse a company in-depth for personal investment if it meets the basic parameters or when I analyse any company for the response to any reader’s query, then it may take a few weeks.
It took us about 2 weeks each to analyse Rain Industries Ltd and Ashok Leyland Ltd.
2) Should one set a time limit in the first place?
One should put a check to the amount of material to be analysed and not a limit on the time spent. As an investor analyses more & more companies, then the time required for him to analyse each additional company would keep on falling with experience. Initially, the analysis would take more time and rightly so.
I prefer to analyse:
- last 10 years’ financial numbers,
- read all the annual reports available in the public domain (Read: Understanding The Annual Report Of A Company)
- all the credit rating reports available since the start of rating coverage (Read: 7 Important Reasons Why Every Stock Investor Should Read Credit Rating Reports)
- go through the entire company website,
- read investor presentation on the company website,
- read the transcript of some of the latest conference calls,
- read the quarterly results since last financial year-end (Read: Understanding the Quarterly Results Filings of Companies)
- do a Google search about the company and read key articles.
The material mentioned above would present an investor with most of the relevant information available about the company in the public domain.
3) How do you know where to begin?
- For filtering, begin with Screener and filter companies based on one’s preferred parameters.
- and then and keep on rejecting the companies that do not meet basic criteria. The customisable excel template helps at this stage.
- Later on, the investor should proceed with the study of the documents mentioned above.
4) And how does one realize which would logically be the next step?
While analysing the financial data and reading annual report etc., the investor will keep on facing questions about the company and its activities. Seeking answers to these questions will keep on guiding the investor ahead in the analysis journey.
5) What to do in case one does not find sufficient data (even though there is no dearth of sources of Secondary Data) for a particular step in the framework of the analysis? Most importantly in case of data is not available how to use surrogate indices?
It is advisable to avoid the company where sufficient data as per investor’s preference is not available. Such companies may present negative surprises to the investor later on. Also, there is no dearth of companies in Indian markets. It is advised that the investor should move ahead to the next company.
6) Because over and above the framework you have laid out to analyze businesses I have seen in all your “Stock Analysis” articles a story which connects the dots for the readers. (For e.g. you began the analysis of this company by stating the health of the company during FY 08-10.) How do you build upon this?
Thanks! I am happy that you could observe this. I appreciate the keen eye of observation that you possess.
As mentioned above in response to point no. (4), the attempts by the investor to keep finding the answers to the questions that come to her mind while analysing the financial numbers and other documents keep on leading the investor to other relevant aspects of the company and related information. This leads to the investor getting clarity about what all is happening with the company at a given point of time and what were the major decisions taken by the company in the past and preferably the motivation of the company management/promoters behind those decisions.
Hope it clarifies your queries!
All the best for your investing journey!
Dr. Vijay Malik
How do we take notes while doing analysis
- What tool/software do you use to highlight in the red box in images?
- How do you normally read and store annual reports, credit reports? Download, underline with pen/pencil/ highlighter, store in a box file OR everything is online because to read online causes strain to the eyes
Thanks for writing to me!
1) What tool/software do you use to highlight in the red box in images?
I use software: Paint.net for doing the highlighting on the images.
2) How do you normally read and store annual reports, credit reports? Download, underline with pen/pencil/ highlighter, store in a box file OR everything is online because to read online causes strain to the eyes
I read annual reports on the laptop/tablet and keep making notes in a separate word document simultaneously. I do not store these reports as they are readily available on public sources.
All the best for your investing journey!
Dr. Vijay Malik
Sum of the parts method of stock analysis
Sir after reading this and a book written by John Greenblatt I searched in screener and found and analysed with the knowledge I learned from your blog. Please have a look and correct me if you have any spare time thanks and regards
At today price of ₹800, the enterprise value is ₹485 cr which comes to 4 EV/EBITDA and the earnings yield is 25% and assuming the MCap to be at 750 cr the enterprise value is 645 cr operating profit of 125 cr the EV/EBITDA 5 and the PE Will be 10.
- At the present EBIT/ enterprise value the EARNING YIELD IS 25% and at 750 cr MCap and EV OF 645 the EARNING YIELD IS 20%
- Even on taking the media alone the revenue is 341 cr and operating profit is 95 Cr and the net profit is 58 cr on media alone even if media segment to be valued at 10 EV/EBITDA this comes to 950 cr
- Or even on market cap to sales of 2, it is 700 cr without finance segment
- Now the current investment and non-current investment comes to nearly 110 which I have not considered
- On the finance segment, there is 300 cr which is fetching around 29 cr operating profit and 21 cr net profit. This at least we can give a 50 cr MCap
- Lastly 209 cr investment in debentures in the real estate
- The sales growth has consistently above 8% profit growth above 15% this time is above 30% even if take the total balance sheet value as an asset which is 637 cr and net profit 81 the return on the total assets is above 12.5% the RoCE is consistent above 30% the return on equity this Fy is 15%.
- The growth factor is 6 P SCORE IS 9 and Alt Z score is 6 and modified c score 1 the current book value is 700.
- No debt 90 yr. history the management is conservative in rewarding dividend but have never given negative result in the last many years.
- Finally, if they decide to merge the Sandesh Procon Pvt. Ltd with the parent company the same way they merged Sandesh Digital that value unlocking has huge potential.
- Now for an enterprise value of just 485 cr backed by asset and cash and equity of more than 880 cr, there can be very limited downside from here and even assuming a fare EV/EBITDA of 5/6 the market cap should be above 750/850 cr
Discl. I have bought a small qty
Thanks for writing to me and providing your valuable inputs on The Sandesh Ltd.
I appreciate the work done by you while analysing the company from “Sum of the parts” methodology in which you have tried to look at each of the business segments, assets, investments done by the company and have tried to opine the valuation levels at which the company is available currently.
I as an investor believe that when we try to analyse any company from the sum of the parts method, then we should analyse each segment as a separate company altogether and assess the performance of such parts under the framework of financial, business, management competence for this segment, operating efficiency of each segment, comparison with peers of each segment.
Once we have done the in-depth analysis of each of the parts as separate businesses, only then we should combine them together.
Many times, when investors value the holding companies or conglomerates, then I have noticed that each business segment does not get the deserved attention of in-depth analysis that it would have if the business segment were a different company altogether.
Moreover, due to the lack of granular information details, many times, it is not possible to properly analyse each business segment. Therefore, most of the times, conglomerates/holding companies trade at a discount to the scenario where all the business segments are hived off into different companies.
On similar lines of the above argument, the value unlocking happens mostly when a business segment is demerged from a holding company. Therefore, I am not sure whether merging an entity in itself would lead to value unlocking.
After reading your analysis, I find that you may conduct further in-depth analysis of each business segment before you make a final opinion about the company.
All the best for your investing journey!
- To know about the stocks in our portfolio, you may subscribe to the premium service: Follow My Portfolio with Latest Buy/Sell Transactions Updates
- To learn our stock investing approach “Peaceful Investing” by videos, you may subscribe to “Peaceful Investing” Workshop-on-Demand
- To download our customized stock analysis excel template: Click Here
- Learn about our stock analysis approach in the e-book: “Peaceful Investing – A Simple Guide to Hassle-free Stock Investing”
- Read more company analysis in the e-book series: Company Analyses
- To register for our upcoming full-day “Peaceful Investing” workshop teaching in-depth fundamental analysis & portfolio management: Click Here
- To pre-register free/express interest for an investing workshop in your city: click here
I would be happy to learn about your feedback on this series of articles and your experiences of stock investing. You may share your inputs in the comments section below.